This episode, we bring you some more commentary and perspective on theological boundaries in Islam from the Blue Bottle coffee shop in Culver City, California. This episode discusses, amongst many things, Haroon Mogul’s Muslims Need A New Definition of Islam In Order To Survive.
“I believe the way forward is to bring about a new definition of Islam that will coexist alongside the ones we already have.” — Haroon Moghul
Question: what are the most important institutions Muslims should be building, particularly in the West (given the absence of a khilāfah)?
Answer: (1) upgrade the skill set of imams, muftis, and other religious leaders. They need to understand where we are culturally. (2) We need to change the dynamo which takes us to the masjid, that encourages us to fast, that will allow us to put up with and tolerate hostility directed towards us, that will engender a love of Allah and Prophet Muhammad, versus a dogged insistence on identity formation. Much of the issue at hand now is Muslim institutions reflect and encourage identity politics versus a message and vision that has a solid theology at its core. If Muslims continue to develop institutions that are secular at their heart then they will continue to produce secular Muslims. We must abandon the idea that we are simply one amongst many groups in (a multicultural) society jostling for our share of rights. Instead, we should see ourselves as a vehicle that will bring light, guidance, balance, wisdom, compassion, justice, and the ultimate culmination of the so-called Abrahamic vision. We have an obligation to proclaim tawhīd, to proclaim the Message of Islam, to make to core of what justifies our existence here, in a predominantly non-Muslim land, da’wah oriented, instead of endlessly firefighting the various sundry needs which are particular to the Muslim community, such as the building of masājid, access to halāl meat, etc. These issues should be seen as subsets of a broader vision to give da’wah. We need a charismatic proclamation of Truth.